If you’ve ever sold something and then realized you made about four dollars an hour, you’re in good company. Pricing is the first thing almost every maker gets wrong, usually in the same direction: too low. The fix isn’t a magic multiplier. It’s counting everything once.
The formula
- Materials for one item.
- Your time: minutes to make it, times an hourly rate.
- Overhead: a share of the things the shop pays for that aren’t inside any one item.
- Profit on top, so the shop has money to grow.
- Selling fees, worked in so they come out of the buyer’s price, not yours.
Steps 1 to 4 are your cost plus profit. Step 5 turns that into a price. Here’s each one.
1. Materials: your share of every supply
Count the materials that go into one item, at what you paid for them. If a $45 batch of wax, wicks and fragrance makes 30 candles, that’s $1.50 a candle. Don’t forget the small stuff: the jar, the label, the dust bag, the thank-you card. Ten cents here and there adds up to real money by the hundredth sale.
2. Your time: yes, it counts
Time the whole thing, including setup, drying, packing and cleanup, then multiply by an hourly rate. A good starting point is what you’d earn doing something else for that hour, often $15–$25. Leaving your time out feels generous, but it means the price only works as long as your time is free. The day you get busy, or want help, it stops working.
3. Overhead: the costs that hide
Tools that wear out, the electricity for the kiln, market booth fees, software, printer ink. Add them up for a month and divide by how many items you make in a month. Or start with 10% of your materials and time, and refine it once you have a few months of receipts.
4. Profit: the shop gets paid too
Your hourly rate pays you. Profit pays the shop: new equipment, a bulk order of supplies, the slow month. Something like 20–30% of your cost is a common place to start.
5. Fees: divide, don’t add
If you sell on Etsy, a US shop pays about 9.5% of the order plus $0.45 in fees (listing, transaction and payment processing). The tempting move is to add 9.5% to your cost. But the fees are taken from the final price, including the part you added for fees, so you come up short. Instead, divide:
Price = (cost + profit + fixed fees) ÷ (1 − fee percentage)
The pricing calculator does this division for you.
A worked example: a soy candle
| Wax, wick, fragrance and jar | $4.10 |
| Label and box | $0.90 |
| 15 minutes at $20 an hour | $5.00 |
| Overhead at 10% | $1.00 |
| Cost | $11.00 |
|---|---|
| Profit at 25% | $2.75 |
| What the candle needs to bring in | $13.75 |
At a market, paid in cash, that’s a $14 candle. On Etsy, (13.75 + 0.45) ÷ (1 − 0.095) = $15.69, so a $16 candle, which leaves about $1.97 for Etsy and the rest for you.
Then look at the market
Now compare your price with similar items. Three things can happen:
- Yours is in the same range. Great. Go.
- Yours is higher. Don’t just cut the price, because that cuts your pay. Look for a cheaper supplier, buy in bulk, make in batches to save time, or make yours clearly better: nicer packaging, a story, a size nobody else offers.
- Yours is lower. You’re probably underpricing. Customers often read a low price as low quality. Try the higher price on your next batch.
The wholesale test
Shops that buy to resell usually pay about half of the retail price. Even if you never plan to sell wholesale, it’s a good check: at half your price, are your materials, time and overhead still covered? If not, your retail price has no room in it, and one bad month will show it.
Common mistakes
- Materials × 2. It ignores your time, which is usually the biggest cost in handmade work.
- Forgetting packaging and shipping. If you offer free shipping, the label is part of your cost.
- Pricing once and never again. Supply prices change. Check your numbers whenever a supplier raises prices, and at least once a year.
- Pricing for your friends. Your friends aren’t your customers. Your customers are the people who see it and want it.
When to raise your prices
When you sell out often, when you have a waiting list, when a material goes up, or when you notice you’re dreading an order because it doesn’t pay. Raising a price by a dollar or two rarely loses the customers who love your work.